Editor's Notes: American Jews are changing after Oct. 7, but we cannot abandon them - comment
Our obligations to fellow Jews extend to those who continue to disagree with us. They are our brothers and sisters, and I’m not willing to give them up
Assessment
The piece argues that American Jews are undergoing a transformation since October 7, but insists the bond between Israeli and American Jews must hold even across deep political disagreements. The author stakes out a position against writing off those who dissent from mainstream Israeli views. The real test will be whether this call for unity can survive the next round of policy clashes or security crises that sharpen divisions.